I have read a number of books in which writers attempt to
explain complicated concepts of modern physics, Einsteinian relativity, quantum
physics, string theory, and the like. These writers employ different strategies
in their attempts to make comprehensible to an intelligent lay reader
complicated concepts. Most of them don't succeed. One of the most difficult
concepts in Einsteinian relativity is the concept of time dilation. Time
dilation refers to the idea that if you travel at an extremely high rate of
speed, say, 95% of the speed of light, time for you slows down. Or to put it
another way, time seems to pass in a normal fashion for you but in the world
through which you're traveling it speeds up. This means for instance that if
you travel on a rocket ship for a year at 95% of the speed of light, when you
return to your starting point you'll discover that eight hundred years have
passed while for you only one year has passed. I understand what time dilation
is, but I don't understand why and how it works. It's been proven repeatedly
through various experiments. It's a fact that it works, that it exists. I just
want to understand why.
Christophe Galfard, the author The Universe in Your Hand: A Journey Through Space, Time, and Beyond
(Flatiron Books, 2016), invites
the reader to imagine that he is sitting at night on the beach with friends
looking up at the stars. Suddenly his mind leaves his body and soars up into
the cosmos. From this perspective the reader oversees the history of the solar
system which ends billions of years hence in the sun's explosion. We plunge
into the core of the sun, visit black holes, study atomic particles up close,
learn about atomic structures and quantum forces. During these visits Galyard shows the reader
how different physical principles work.
The premise of the book: that by understanding the
scientific principles of the universe, Newtonian physics, Einsteinian
relativistic physics, quantum physics, string theory, and the like, mankind
will one day have enough Information to be able to ensure the survival of the
human race into the future before the sun explodes.
This strategy does work in a certain way. The author
succeeds better than some others In making these concepts comprehensible. But I
found his strategy condescending, inviting the reader to pretend that he is
soaring through space or shrinking to a minuscule size and traveling around
with quarks and electrons and protons and various other particles. In essence, it
insults the reader's intelligence. Moreover, Galyard spends so much time
setting up these journeys and joshing with the reader about what he’s learned
that he denies himself the opportunity for explaining his subject in more
depth. What I want from a book like this is clear writing and careful
explanation of difficult concepts, not pandering.
Each chapter tackles a different aspect of cosmology: moving
from the solar system to the universe to atomic particles and quantum particles
to black holes and the Big Bang and string theory. An introductory note promises that the book
will use only one equation (E=MC2) and that the reader will take a
“journey through the universe as it is understood by science today. It is my deepest belief that we can all
understand this stuff.”
I appreciate Galyard's attempt to explain difficult
concepts, but his strategy is sometimes cloying.
No comments:
Post a Comment